Landscape connectivity in extensive livestock farming: an adaptive approach to the land sharing and land sparing dilemma

This study investigates the “land sharing” versus “land sparing” dilemma in the context of extensive cattle ranching in Chiapas, Mexico. Employing a comprehensive methodology that synthesizes various systems and uses a normalized matrix for relative priority assessment, we identified several geograp...

Full description

Bibliographic Details
Main Authors: Pulido-Herrera, Luz Astrid, Sepulveda, Claudia, Jiménez, Jose Antonio, Betanzos Simon, Juan Eduardo
Format: Artículo
Language:Inglés
Published: 2025
Subjects:
Online Access:https://repositorio.catie.ac.cr/handle/11554/12798
_version_ 1854967146692476928
author Pulido-Herrera, Luz Astrid
Sepulveda, Claudia
Jiménez, Jose Antonio
Betanzos Simon, Juan Eduardo
author_browse Betanzos Simon, Juan Eduardo
Jiménez, Jose Antonio
Pulido-Herrera, Luz Astrid
Sepulveda, Claudia
author_facet Pulido-Herrera, Luz Astrid
Sepulveda, Claudia
Jiménez, Jose Antonio
Betanzos Simon, Juan Eduardo
author_sort Pulido-Herrera, Luz Astrid
collection Repositorio CATIE
description This study investigates the “land sharing” versus “land sparing” dilemma in the context of extensive cattle ranching in Chiapas, Mexico. Employing a comprehensive methodology that synthesizes various systems and uses a normalized matrix for relative priority assessment, we identified several geographic variables as zoning criteria. These criteria encompass the hemerobic index, proximity to structurally intact forests, fire frequency, and terrain slope, aiming to identify areas optimal for conservation. Our results highlight properties with high conservation potential and propose two distinct connectivity scenarios, both excluding currently preserved areas. The analysis focuses on the interplay between connectivity and hemeroby, identifying human-influenced regions within the landscape and emphasizing the importance of tree conservation in agricultural contexts for biodiversity preservation. By tackling the “land sharing” vs. “land sparing” debate, the study underscores the necessity of sustainable livestock practices and the critical role of connectivity in ranching landscapes for ecosystem preservation.
format Artículo
id RepoCATIE12798
institution Centro Agronómico Tropical de Investigación y Enseñanza
language Inglés
publishDate 2025
publishDateRange 2025
publishDateSort 2025
record_format dspace
spelling RepoCATIE127982025-05-14T22:53:19Z Landscape connectivity in extensive livestock farming: an adaptive approach to the land sharing and land sparing dilemma Pulido-Herrera, Luz Astrid Sepulveda, Claudia Jiménez, Jose Antonio Betanzos Simon, Juan Eduardo Livestock Landscape connectivity AbE Hemeroby Multi-criteria analysis Sede Central ODS 12 - Producción y consumo responsables ODS 13 - Acción por el clima ODS 15 - Vida de ecosistemas terrestres This study investigates the “land sharing” versus “land sparing” dilemma in the context of extensive cattle ranching in Chiapas, Mexico. Employing a comprehensive methodology that synthesizes various systems and uses a normalized matrix for relative priority assessment, we identified several geographic variables as zoning criteria. These criteria encompass the hemerobic index, proximity to structurally intact forests, fire frequency, and terrain slope, aiming to identify areas optimal for conservation. Our results highlight properties with high conservation potential and propose two distinct connectivity scenarios, both excluding currently preserved areas. The analysis focuses on the interplay between connectivity and hemeroby, identifying human-influenced regions within the landscape and emphasizing the importance of tree conservation in agricultural contexts for biodiversity preservation. By tackling the “land sharing” vs. “land sparing” debate, the study underscores the necessity of sustainable livestock practices and the critical role of connectivity in ranching landscapes for ecosystem preservation. 2025-05-13T21:31:59Z 2025-05-13T21:31:59Z 2024-05-08 Artículo https://repositorio.catie.ac.cr/handle/11554/12798 openAccess en Frontiers in Sustainable Food Systems https://doi.org/10.3389/fsufs.2024.1345517 16 páginas application/pdf
spellingShingle Livestock
Landscape connectivity
AbE
Hemeroby
Multi-criteria analysis
Sede Central
ODS 12 - Producción y consumo responsables
ODS 13 - Acción por el clima
ODS 15 - Vida de ecosistemas terrestres
Pulido-Herrera, Luz Astrid
Sepulveda, Claudia
Jiménez, Jose Antonio
Betanzos Simon, Juan Eduardo
Landscape connectivity in extensive livestock farming: an adaptive approach to the land sharing and land sparing dilemma
title Landscape connectivity in extensive livestock farming: an adaptive approach to the land sharing and land sparing dilemma
title_full Landscape connectivity in extensive livestock farming: an adaptive approach to the land sharing and land sparing dilemma
title_fullStr Landscape connectivity in extensive livestock farming: an adaptive approach to the land sharing and land sparing dilemma
title_full_unstemmed Landscape connectivity in extensive livestock farming: an adaptive approach to the land sharing and land sparing dilemma
title_short Landscape connectivity in extensive livestock farming: an adaptive approach to the land sharing and land sparing dilemma
title_sort landscape connectivity in extensive livestock farming an adaptive approach to the land sharing and land sparing dilemma
topic Livestock
Landscape connectivity
AbE
Hemeroby
Multi-criteria analysis
Sede Central
ODS 12 - Producción y consumo responsables
ODS 13 - Acción por el clima
ODS 15 - Vida de ecosistemas terrestres
url https://repositorio.catie.ac.cr/handle/11554/12798
work_keys_str_mv AT pulidoherreraluzastrid landscapeconnectivityinextensivelivestockfarminganadaptiveapproachtothelandsharingandlandsparingdilemma
AT sepulvedaclaudia landscapeconnectivityinextensivelivestockfarminganadaptiveapproachtothelandsharingandlandsparingdilemma
AT jimenezjoseantonio landscapeconnectivityinextensivelivestockfarminganadaptiveapproachtothelandsharingandlandsparingdilemma
AT betanzossimonjuaneduardo landscapeconnectivityinextensivelivestockfarminganadaptiveapproachtothelandsharingandlandsparingdilemma