Revisiting the relationship between stomatal size and speed across species – a meta‐analysis
The rate of stomatal opening and closure in response to changes in light affects leaf photosynthesis and water use. However, it is unclear how strongly stomatal size ( SS ) and density ( SD ) influence stomatal conductance ( g s ) kinetics, and whether variation arises from methodological difference...
| Autores principales: | , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , |
|---|---|
| Formato: | Journal Article |
| Lenguaje: | Inglés |
| Publicado: |
Wiley
2025
|
| Materias: | |
| Acceso en línea: | https://hdl.handle.net/10568/179478 |
| _version_ | 1855523982391902208 |
|---|---|
| author | Woning, Nik Al‐Salman, Yazen Kaiser, Elias Berman, Sarah R. Brendel, Oliver Cano, Francisco Javier Carpentier, Sebastien Centritto, Mauro Drake, Paul L. Durand, Maxime Eyland, David Franks, Peter J. Gerardin, Theo Ghannoum, Oula Haworth, Matthew Kübarsepp, Liisa Lawson, Tracy Le Thiec, Didier Li, Yong Marcelis, Leo F. M. Marino, Giovanni McAusland, Lorna Muir, Christopher D. Niinemets, Ülo Nunes, Tiago D. G. Raissig, Michael T. Sakoda, Kazuma Sugiura, Daisuke Tosens, Tiina Zhang, Qiangqiang Zhang, Ningyi Vialet‐Chabrand, Silvere |
| author_browse | Al‐Salman, Yazen Berman, Sarah R. Brendel, Oliver Cano, Francisco Javier Carpentier, Sebastien Centritto, Mauro Drake, Paul L. Durand, Maxime Eyland, David Franks, Peter J. Gerardin, Theo Ghannoum, Oula Haworth, Matthew Kaiser, Elias Kübarsepp, Liisa Lawson, Tracy Le Thiec, Didier Li, Yong Marcelis, Leo F. M. Marino, Giovanni McAusland, Lorna Muir, Christopher D. Niinemets, Ülo Nunes, Tiago D. G. Raissig, Michael T. Sakoda, Kazuma Sugiura, Daisuke Tosens, Tiina Vialet‐Chabrand, Silvere Woning, Nik Zhang, Ningyi Zhang, Qiangqiang |
| author_facet | Woning, Nik Al‐Salman, Yazen Kaiser, Elias Berman, Sarah R. Brendel, Oliver Cano, Francisco Javier Carpentier, Sebastien Centritto, Mauro Drake, Paul L. Durand, Maxime Eyland, David Franks, Peter J. Gerardin, Theo Ghannoum, Oula Haworth, Matthew Kübarsepp, Liisa Lawson, Tracy Le Thiec, Didier Li, Yong Marcelis, Leo F. M. Marino, Giovanni McAusland, Lorna Muir, Christopher D. Niinemets, Ülo Nunes, Tiago D. G. Raissig, Michael T. Sakoda, Kazuma Sugiura, Daisuke Tosens, Tiina Zhang, Qiangqiang Zhang, Ningyi Vialet‐Chabrand, Silvere |
| author_sort | Woning, Nik |
| collection | Repository of Agricultural Research Outputs (CGSpace) |
| description | The rate of stomatal opening and closure in response to changes in light affects leaf photosynthesis and water use. However, it is unclear how strongly stomatal size ( SS ) and density ( SD ) influence stomatal conductance ( g s ) kinetics, and whether variation arises from methodological differences, guard cell type or degree of amphistomaty. We divided published records combining stomatal kinetics and anatomical traits from 89 species into kidney and dumbbell‐shaped guard cells, and evaluated four dynamic g s models on them. We derived the time constant for an exponential response of g s ( τ ) and the maximum rate of change ( Sl max ) as well as the ratio of adaxial/abaxial SD ( rSD ). We found significant differences in parameter estimation between models. Stomatal anatomical traits and kinetic parameters showed large variation across species. While individual anatomical features ( SS , SD , rSD and guard cell types) were weakly correlated with stomatal response speed ( τ and Sl max ), interactions between these features showed significant effects, demonstrating that kinetic performance arises from synergistic rather than additive anatomical relationships. Our results call for the use of our unified modeling approach, challenge the generality of the observation that smaller stomata move faster across species and suggest rSD as an understudied driver of stomatal kinetics. |
| format | Journal Article |
| id | CGSpace179478 |
| institution | CGIAR Consortium |
| language | Inglés |
| publishDate | 2025 |
| publishDateRange | 2025 |
| publishDateSort | 2025 |
| publisher | Wiley |
| publisherStr | Wiley |
| record_format | dspace |
| spelling | CGSpace1794782026-01-08T02:07:23Z Revisiting the relationship between stomatal size and speed across species – a meta‐analysis Woning, Nik Al‐Salman, Yazen Kaiser, Elias Berman, Sarah R. Brendel, Oliver Cano, Francisco Javier Carpentier, Sebastien Centritto, Mauro Drake, Paul L. Durand, Maxime Eyland, David Franks, Peter J. Gerardin, Theo Ghannoum, Oula Haworth, Matthew Kübarsepp, Liisa Lawson, Tracy Le Thiec, Didier Li, Yong Marcelis, Leo F. M. Marino, Giovanni McAusland, Lorna Muir, Christopher D. Niinemets, Ülo Nunes, Tiago D. G. Raissig, Michael T. Sakoda, Kazuma Sugiura, Daisuke Tosens, Tiina Zhang, Qiangqiang Zhang, Ningyi Vialet‐Chabrand, Silvere stomatal conductance modelling species diversity kinetics The rate of stomatal opening and closure in response to changes in light affects leaf photosynthesis and water use. However, it is unclear how strongly stomatal size ( SS ) and density ( SD ) influence stomatal conductance ( g s ) kinetics, and whether variation arises from methodological differences, guard cell type or degree of amphistomaty. We divided published records combining stomatal kinetics and anatomical traits from 89 species into kidney and dumbbell‐shaped guard cells, and evaluated four dynamic g s models on them. We derived the time constant for an exponential response of g s ( τ ) and the maximum rate of change ( Sl max ) as well as the ratio of adaxial/abaxial SD ( rSD ). We found significant differences in parameter estimation between models. Stomatal anatomical traits and kinetic parameters showed large variation across species. While individual anatomical features ( SS , SD , rSD and guard cell types) were weakly correlated with stomatal response speed ( τ and Sl max ), interactions between these features showed significant effects, demonstrating that kinetic performance arises from synergistic rather than additive anatomical relationships. Our results call for the use of our unified modeling approach, challenge the generality of the observation that smaller stomata move faster across species and suggest rSD as an understudied driver of stomatal kinetics. 2025-12-28 2026-01-07T12:59:53Z 2026-01-07T12:59:53Z Journal Article https://hdl.handle.net/10568/179478 en Open Access application/pdf Wiley Woning, N.; Al‐Salman, Y.; Kaiser, E.; Berman, S.R.; Brendel, O.; Cano, F.J.; Carpentier, S.; Centritto, M.; Drake, P.L.; Durand, M.; Eyland, D.; Franks, P.J.; Gerardin, T.; Ghannoum, O.; Haworth, M.; Kübarsepp, L.; Lawson, T.; Le Thiec, D.; Li, Y.; Marcelis, L.F.M.; Marino, G.; McAusland, L.; Muir, C.D.; Niinemets, Ü.; Nunes, T.D.G.; Raissig, M.T.; Sakoda, K.; Sugiura, D.; Tosens, T.; Zhang, Q.; Zhang, N.; Vialet‐Chabrand, S. (2025) Revisiting the relationship between stomatal size and speed across species – a meta‐analysis. New Phytologist , Online first paper(2025-12-28). ISSN: 0028-646X |
| spellingShingle | stomatal conductance modelling species diversity kinetics Woning, Nik Al‐Salman, Yazen Kaiser, Elias Berman, Sarah R. Brendel, Oliver Cano, Francisco Javier Carpentier, Sebastien Centritto, Mauro Drake, Paul L. Durand, Maxime Eyland, David Franks, Peter J. Gerardin, Theo Ghannoum, Oula Haworth, Matthew Kübarsepp, Liisa Lawson, Tracy Le Thiec, Didier Li, Yong Marcelis, Leo F. M. Marino, Giovanni McAusland, Lorna Muir, Christopher D. Niinemets, Ülo Nunes, Tiago D. G. Raissig, Michael T. Sakoda, Kazuma Sugiura, Daisuke Tosens, Tiina Zhang, Qiangqiang Zhang, Ningyi Vialet‐Chabrand, Silvere Revisiting the relationship between stomatal size and speed across species – a meta‐analysis |
| title | Revisiting the relationship between stomatal size and speed across species – a meta‐analysis |
| title_full | Revisiting the relationship between stomatal size and speed across species – a meta‐analysis |
| title_fullStr | Revisiting the relationship between stomatal size and speed across species – a meta‐analysis |
| title_full_unstemmed | Revisiting the relationship between stomatal size and speed across species – a meta‐analysis |
| title_short | Revisiting the relationship between stomatal size and speed across species – a meta‐analysis |
| title_sort | revisiting the relationship between stomatal size and speed across species a meta analysis |
| topic | stomatal conductance modelling species diversity kinetics |
| url | https://hdl.handle.net/10568/179478 |
| work_keys_str_mv | AT woningnik revisitingtherelationshipbetweenstomatalsizeandspeedacrossspeciesametaanalysis AT alsalmanyazen revisitingtherelationshipbetweenstomatalsizeandspeedacrossspeciesametaanalysis AT kaiserelias revisitingtherelationshipbetweenstomatalsizeandspeedacrossspeciesametaanalysis AT bermansarahr revisitingtherelationshipbetweenstomatalsizeandspeedacrossspeciesametaanalysis AT brendeloliver revisitingtherelationshipbetweenstomatalsizeandspeedacrossspeciesametaanalysis AT canofranciscojavier revisitingtherelationshipbetweenstomatalsizeandspeedacrossspeciesametaanalysis AT carpentiersebastien revisitingtherelationshipbetweenstomatalsizeandspeedacrossspeciesametaanalysis AT centrittomauro revisitingtherelationshipbetweenstomatalsizeandspeedacrossspeciesametaanalysis AT drakepaull revisitingtherelationshipbetweenstomatalsizeandspeedacrossspeciesametaanalysis AT durandmaxime revisitingtherelationshipbetweenstomatalsizeandspeedacrossspeciesametaanalysis AT eylanddavid revisitingtherelationshipbetweenstomatalsizeandspeedacrossspeciesametaanalysis AT frankspeterj revisitingtherelationshipbetweenstomatalsizeandspeedacrossspeciesametaanalysis AT gerardintheo revisitingtherelationshipbetweenstomatalsizeandspeedacrossspeciesametaanalysis AT ghannoumoula revisitingtherelationshipbetweenstomatalsizeandspeedacrossspeciesametaanalysis AT haworthmatthew revisitingtherelationshipbetweenstomatalsizeandspeedacrossspeciesametaanalysis AT kubarseppliisa revisitingtherelationshipbetweenstomatalsizeandspeedacrossspeciesametaanalysis AT lawsontracy revisitingtherelationshipbetweenstomatalsizeandspeedacrossspeciesametaanalysis AT lethiecdidier revisitingtherelationshipbetweenstomatalsizeandspeedacrossspeciesametaanalysis AT liyong revisitingtherelationshipbetweenstomatalsizeandspeedacrossspeciesametaanalysis AT marcelisleofm revisitingtherelationshipbetweenstomatalsizeandspeedacrossspeciesametaanalysis AT marinogiovanni revisitingtherelationshipbetweenstomatalsizeandspeedacrossspeciesametaanalysis AT mcauslandlorna revisitingtherelationshipbetweenstomatalsizeandspeedacrossspeciesametaanalysis AT muirchristopherd revisitingtherelationshipbetweenstomatalsizeandspeedacrossspeciesametaanalysis AT niinemetsulo revisitingtherelationshipbetweenstomatalsizeandspeedacrossspeciesametaanalysis AT nunestiagodg revisitingtherelationshipbetweenstomatalsizeandspeedacrossspeciesametaanalysis AT raissigmichaelt revisitingtherelationshipbetweenstomatalsizeandspeedacrossspeciesametaanalysis AT sakodakazuma revisitingtherelationshipbetweenstomatalsizeandspeedacrossspeciesametaanalysis AT sugiuradaisuke revisitingtherelationshipbetweenstomatalsizeandspeedacrossspeciesametaanalysis AT tosenstiina revisitingtherelationshipbetweenstomatalsizeandspeedacrossspeciesametaanalysis AT zhangqiangqiang revisitingtherelationshipbetweenstomatalsizeandspeedacrossspeciesametaanalysis AT zhangningyi revisitingtherelationshipbetweenstomatalsizeandspeedacrossspeciesametaanalysis AT vialetchabrandsilvere revisitingtherelationshipbetweenstomatalsizeandspeedacrossspeciesametaanalysis |