Reconciling conservation and development requires enhanced integration and broader aims: A cross- continental assessment of landscape approaches
Expectations for agricultural landscapes in subtropical and tropical regions are high, aiming for conservation and development amid climate change, unfair trade, poverty, and environmental degradation. Landscape approaches (LAs) are gaining momentum as means to reconcile expectations, although they...
| Main Authors: | , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , |
|---|---|
| Format: | Journal Article |
| Language: | Inglés |
| Published: |
Elsevier
2024
|
| Subjects: | |
| Online Access: | https://hdl.handle.net/10568/152357 |
| _version_ | 1855517977478168576 |
|---|---|
| author | Estrada Carmona, Natalia Carmenta, Rachel Reed, James Betemariam, Ermias Declerck, Fabrice Falk, Thomas Hart, Abigail K Jones, Sarah K Kleinschroth, Fritz McCartney, Matthew P. Meinzen-Dick, Ruth S. Milder, Jeff Quintero, Marcela Remans, Roseline Valbuena, Diego Willement, Louise Zanzanaini, Camilla Zhang, Wei |
| author_browse | Betemariam, Ermias Carmenta, Rachel Declerck, Fabrice Estrada Carmona, Natalia Falk, Thomas Hart, Abigail K Jones, Sarah K Kleinschroth, Fritz McCartney, Matthew P. Meinzen-Dick, Ruth S. Milder, Jeff Quintero, Marcela Reed, James Remans, Roseline Valbuena, Diego Willement, Louise Zanzanaini, Camilla Zhang, Wei |
| author_facet | Estrada Carmona, Natalia Carmenta, Rachel Reed, James Betemariam, Ermias Declerck, Fabrice Falk, Thomas Hart, Abigail K Jones, Sarah K Kleinschroth, Fritz McCartney, Matthew P. Meinzen-Dick, Ruth S. Milder, Jeff Quintero, Marcela Remans, Roseline Valbuena, Diego Willement, Louise Zanzanaini, Camilla Zhang, Wei |
| author_sort | Estrada Carmona, Natalia |
| collection | Repository of Agricultural Research Outputs (CGSpace) |
| description | Expectations for agricultural landscapes in subtropical and tropical regions are high, aiming for conservation and development amid climate change, unfair trade, poverty, and environmental degradation. Landscape approaches (LAs) are gaining momentum as means to reconcile expectations, although they face multiple challenges, including unclear distinctions among LAs and stakeholder involvement. We studied 380 LAs from three continents via questionnaires with landscape managers (2012–2015 and 2021) and identified three LA types through cluster analysis: an ‘‘integrated’’ type with longer-term, multisectoral goals involving various stakeholders early in the design and two shorter-term types focused on sectoral priorities of preservation or production. Better-performing LAs are associated with longevity, inclusivity, and diversified investments across goals, notably those enabling social justice. International stakeholder analysis shows broad support for LAs but identifies gaps between support and LAs’ needs. The growing interest in LAs is promising. Yet, underpinning effective and lasting LAs that reconcile multiple expectations requires better support. |
| format | Journal Article |
| id | CGSpace152357 |
| institution | CGIAR Consortium |
| language | Inglés |
| publishDate | 2024 |
| publishDateRange | 2024 |
| publishDateSort | 2024 |
| publisher | Elsevier |
| publisherStr | Elsevier |
| record_format | dspace |
| spelling | CGSpace1523572025-11-12T05:09:44Z Reconciling conservation and development requires enhanced integration and broader aims: A cross- continental assessment of landscape approaches Estrada Carmona, Natalia Carmenta, Rachel Reed, James Betemariam, Ermias Declerck, Fabrice Falk, Thomas Hart, Abigail K Jones, Sarah K Kleinschroth, Fritz McCartney, Matthew P. Meinzen-Dick, Ruth S. Milder, Jeff Quintero, Marcela Remans, Roseline Valbuena, Diego Willement, Louise Zanzanaini, Camilla Zhang, Wei diversification agriculture resilience landscape approaches Expectations for agricultural landscapes in subtropical and tropical regions are high, aiming for conservation and development amid climate change, unfair trade, poverty, and environmental degradation. Landscape approaches (LAs) are gaining momentum as means to reconcile expectations, although they face multiple challenges, including unclear distinctions among LAs and stakeholder involvement. We studied 380 LAs from three continents via questionnaires with landscape managers (2012–2015 and 2021) and identified three LA types through cluster analysis: an ‘‘integrated’’ type with longer-term, multisectoral goals involving various stakeholders early in the design and two shorter-term types focused on sectoral priorities of preservation or production. Better-performing LAs are associated with longevity, inclusivity, and diversified investments across goals, notably those enabling social justice. International stakeholder analysis shows broad support for LAs but identifies gaps between support and LAs’ needs. The growing interest in LAs is promising. Yet, underpinning effective and lasting LAs that reconcile multiple expectations requires better support. 2024-10 2024-09-23T19:54:46Z 2024-09-23T19:54:46Z Journal Article https://hdl.handle.net/10568/152357 en Open Access application/pdf Elsevier Estrada Carmona, N.; Carmenta, R.; Reed, J.; Betemariam, E.; Declerck, F.; Falk, T.; Hart, A.K.; Jones, S.K.; Kleinschroth, F.; McCartney, M.; Meinzen-Dick, R.; Milder, J.; Quintero, M.; Remans, R.; Valbuena, D.; Willement, L.; Zanzanaini, C.; Zhang, W. (2024) Reconciling conservation and development requires enhanced integration and broader aims: A cross-continental assessment of landscape approaches. One Earth 7 (10) : p.1858 - 1873. ISSN: 2590-3330. |
| spellingShingle | diversification agriculture resilience landscape approaches Estrada Carmona, Natalia Carmenta, Rachel Reed, James Betemariam, Ermias Declerck, Fabrice Falk, Thomas Hart, Abigail K Jones, Sarah K Kleinschroth, Fritz McCartney, Matthew P. Meinzen-Dick, Ruth S. Milder, Jeff Quintero, Marcela Remans, Roseline Valbuena, Diego Willement, Louise Zanzanaini, Camilla Zhang, Wei Reconciling conservation and development requires enhanced integration and broader aims: A cross- continental assessment of landscape approaches |
| title | Reconciling conservation and development requires enhanced integration and broader aims: A cross- continental assessment of landscape approaches |
| title_full | Reconciling conservation and development requires enhanced integration and broader aims: A cross- continental assessment of landscape approaches |
| title_fullStr | Reconciling conservation and development requires enhanced integration and broader aims: A cross- continental assessment of landscape approaches |
| title_full_unstemmed | Reconciling conservation and development requires enhanced integration and broader aims: A cross- continental assessment of landscape approaches |
| title_short | Reconciling conservation and development requires enhanced integration and broader aims: A cross- continental assessment of landscape approaches |
| title_sort | reconciling conservation and development requires enhanced integration and broader aims a cross continental assessment of landscape approaches |
| topic | diversification agriculture resilience landscape approaches |
| url | https://hdl.handle.net/10568/152357 |
| work_keys_str_mv | AT estradacarmonanatalia reconcilingconservationanddevelopmentrequiresenhancedintegrationandbroaderaimsacrosscontinentalassessmentoflandscapeapproaches AT carmentarachel reconcilingconservationanddevelopmentrequiresenhancedintegrationandbroaderaimsacrosscontinentalassessmentoflandscapeapproaches AT reedjames reconcilingconservationanddevelopmentrequiresenhancedintegrationandbroaderaimsacrosscontinentalassessmentoflandscapeapproaches AT betemariamermias reconcilingconservationanddevelopmentrequiresenhancedintegrationandbroaderaimsacrosscontinentalassessmentoflandscapeapproaches AT declerckfabrice reconcilingconservationanddevelopmentrequiresenhancedintegrationandbroaderaimsacrosscontinentalassessmentoflandscapeapproaches AT falkthomas reconcilingconservationanddevelopmentrequiresenhancedintegrationandbroaderaimsacrosscontinentalassessmentoflandscapeapproaches AT hartabigailk reconcilingconservationanddevelopmentrequiresenhancedintegrationandbroaderaimsacrosscontinentalassessmentoflandscapeapproaches AT jonessarahk reconcilingconservationanddevelopmentrequiresenhancedintegrationandbroaderaimsacrosscontinentalassessmentoflandscapeapproaches AT kleinschrothfritz reconcilingconservationanddevelopmentrequiresenhancedintegrationandbroaderaimsacrosscontinentalassessmentoflandscapeapproaches AT mccartneymatthewp reconcilingconservationanddevelopmentrequiresenhancedintegrationandbroaderaimsacrosscontinentalassessmentoflandscapeapproaches AT meinzendickruths reconcilingconservationanddevelopmentrequiresenhancedintegrationandbroaderaimsacrosscontinentalassessmentoflandscapeapproaches AT milderjeff reconcilingconservationanddevelopmentrequiresenhancedintegrationandbroaderaimsacrosscontinentalassessmentoflandscapeapproaches AT quinteromarcela reconcilingconservationanddevelopmentrequiresenhancedintegrationandbroaderaimsacrosscontinentalassessmentoflandscapeapproaches AT remansroseline reconcilingconservationanddevelopmentrequiresenhancedintegrationandbroaderaimsacrosscontinentalassessmentoflandscapeapproaches AT valbuenadiego reconcilingconservationanddevelopmentrequiresenhancedintegrationandbroaderaimsacrosscontinentalassessmentoflandscapeapproaches AT willementlouise reconcilingconservationanddevelopmentrequiresenhancedintegrationandbroaderaimsacrosscontinentalassessmentoflandscapeapproaches AT zanzanainicamilla reconcilingconservationanddevelopmentrequiresenhancedintegrationandbroaderaimsacrosscontinentalassessmentoflandscapeapproaches AT zhangwei reconcilingconservationanddevelopmentrequiresenhancedintegrationandbroaderaimsacrosscontinentalassessmentoflandscapeapproaches |